Despite the Uttarakhand government’s decision to abolish the Patwari system following the Ankita Bhandari murder case, the system remains active in remote areas even after two years. While the first phase saw the establishment of six new police stations and 20 police outposts, the second phase is yet to begin. The State Human Rights Commission has taken serious note of the delay and has sought a detailed report from the government. Meanwhile, advocate Rituparna Uniyal, who challenged the Patwari system in the Supreme Court, has accused the government of contempt of court and is considering filing a contempt petition.
Commission member Giridhar Singh Dharmshaktu has raised concerns over human rights violations in remote hilly areas due to the continued presence of Patwaris in law enforcement. Complaints indicate that local influential figures can easily manipulate Patwaris, leading to weakened law enforcement.
Additionally, many new legal provisions cannot be effectively enforced under the Patwari system. Reports suggest that criminals find it easier to hide in areas still under Patwari jurisdiction, causing persistent law and order issues, including:
- Crimes against women
- Illegal encroachments
- Unregulated high-speed vehicle movement
- Harassment of school students
- Illegal mining activities
- Public disturbances by intoxicated individuals
The State Human Rights Commission has given the government until April 28 to submit a detailed compliance report.
